Atonement

hey guys, anyone out there seen "Atonement" or "Expiación, Deseo y Pecado" ? i have heard its pretty rough....any thoughts? :confused:

I have seen it in Spanish. Beautiful! Very Sad! Possibly too long......

rough? why?

Did you know the gree dress worne by Cecilia won the prize for the most incredible dress from films?

Here it is:
http://www.trendencias.com/2008/01/0...y-en-atonement


It's really sad, that's true. The appearance of Vanessa REdgrave towards the end...unique!

thanks exxcéntrica, that is an amazing dress!:)

I saw it, and it has to be one of the saddest movies I've seen lately.
It's true that at a moment it seems a bit long, but it's a good movie, I liked it. And I liked Kiera Knightley better than the little girl, and the girl got a nomination for the Oscar and Knightley didn't! I just don't understand the academy...

I haven't seen it yet but I read the book some years ago.. I liked it very much.